Skip to main content

What is the IHRA definition and why is it controversial?

Dozens of countries have adopted or endorsed the IHRA's antisemitism definition but critics say it curtails free speech
People participate in a Jewish solidarity march across the Brooklyn Bridge in New York City. The march was held in response to a recent rise in anti-Semitic crimes in the greater New York metropolitan area (AFP)
People participate in a Jewish solidarity march across the Brooklyn Bridge in New York City. The march was held in response to a recent rise in anti-Semitic crimes in the greater New York metropolitan area (AFP)

The International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) definition of antisemitism has become the most widely cited tool for governments and public institutions seeking to identify anti-Jewish hatred. 

And over the past decade, dozens of governments, political parties and public bodies have endorsed the definition or referenced it to show their commitment towards fighting antisemitism. 

Jewish and pro-Israeli groups have welcomed its adoption in universities and governments in Europe and across North America. 

But the definition has sparked controversy, with some critics concerned that it blurs the line between antisemitism and legitimate criticism of Israel. 

What the IHRA definition? 

New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch

Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters

The IHRA working definition identifies antisemitism a "certain perception of Jews, which may be expressed as hatred towards Jews."

The definition, which is non-legally binding, is accompanied by a list of 11 "illustrations" of antisemitism which the IHRA says are intended to "guide" it in its work.

These examples include making claims that Jews control the media and the economy, denying the Holocaust, and accusing Jews of being more loyal to Israel than their own countries.

Seven of the 11 examples include references to Israel. They include claiming that the existence of the state of Israel is a "racist endeavour", and "applying double standard [to Israel] by requiring of it a behaviour not expected or demanded of any other democratic nation".

Origins of the definition  

The definition was coined by antisemitism expert Kenneth Stern in collaboration with other academics for the American Jewish Committee. 

The academic said his definition was created to be used as a research tool for monitoring antisemitism in Europe. 

But after the European Union's Monitoring Centre on Racism and Xenephobia began using the definition in 2005, Stern's definition was formally adopted and promoted by the IHRA in 2016. 

But after facing complaints of misuse, the centre's successor body, the Fundamental Rights Agency, dropped it in 2014.

The pro-Israel Simon Wiesenthal centre, headed by Mark Weitzman, later campaigned for the definition to be reintroduced via the IHRA. 

Why critics find the definition problematic? 

Critics of the definition argue that several examples listed by IHRA conflate antisemitism with anti-Zionism or with political debates over Israel's founding, Palestinian displacement, settlements and occupation. 

In universities, the definition has been used as a basis to cancel events, restrict speakers, and pressure pro-Palestine activism. 

Stern himself has warned that using the definition policing tactic can create a "chilling effect" discouraging discussion on Israel-Palestine. 

Legal experts and academics - including Jewish scholars- have echoed these concerns, highlighting that staff and students can feel anxious discussing Israel-Palestine when the definition is including in disciplinary policies. 

Is there an alternative? 

Frustrated by the IHRA's definition of antisemitism, hundreds of scholars of antisemitism, Jewish history and Middle East politics, published the Jerusalem Declaration on Antisemitism (JDA) in 2021.

The JDA defines antisemitism as discrimination, hostility or violence against Jews "as jews." It uses 15 examples to distinguish anti-Jewish hatred from legitimate political debate. 

Unlike the IHRA, the JDA explicitly states that Zionism, support for boycotts, or arguments that Israeli laws are discriminatory are not antisemitic.  

But the JDA does stress that rhetoric becomes antisemitic when it draws on classic anti-Jewish stereotypes, targets Jews collectively for Israel's actions, or denies Jews equal rights. 

Middle East Eye delivers independent and unrivalled coverage and analysis of the Middle East, North Africa and beyond. To learn more about republishing this content and the associated fees, please fill out this form. More about MEE can be found here.